Tax, tax, tax Tax, tax, tax.
That has become the New York mantra. And it has been making our DMV workers, troopers, courts and others into tax collectors.
The most revealing insight into our state's taxation philosophy is the proposal that will require us to turn in our perfectly good vehicle license plates, and exchange them for different perfectly good license plates — after paying $25. If you would like to keep your old license plate number, that is fine. You will just have to pay about twice as much for that privilege.
State troopers are also encouraged to generate revenue by pulling over and ticketing otherwise law abiding citizens. Obviously, it worries me to highlight this practice. I too am frustrated by the sense that our public safety officers have been pressured to view us as driving dollar signs. It is not their fault, though. They have been instructed to raise sufficient revenue to help pay their salaries. I am certain that these officers resent their new role. They signed up to keep us safe, not to do the tax collecting work of a state with little spending discipline.
To add insult to injury, when these tickets, however minor, are disposed of in court, the state adds another fee for the privilege of availing our otherwise law-abiding citizens of the court system. A very minor, non-moving violation that yields a $25 fine will have tacked onto it an additional $100 surcharge. Cha-ching.
The folly of these desperate acts to raise revenue for the state is in its sheer audacity to focus on raising revenue, at any cost to the taxpayer. You see, the true cost of these various taxes and surcharges is much higher, and is a terrible economic waste. To understand this, and to see why the state has it wrong, we must understand how economists and New York politicians differ in their view of taxes.
Taxes are a necessary part of any free-market democracy. Freedom allows us to refuse to pay for items we do not want. It also allows us to refuse to pay for things from which we derive benefit but claim we do not. For instance, we collectively benefit from public-safety officers that keep us safe and secure, but each of us would prefer to have others pay our share, if possible.
It is such provision of these public services that economists argue is an appropriate role for taxation. Most economists also recognize that the public-service model has limitations because it disconnects those taxpayers who pay for the service from those who serve the taxpayers. When we purchase a meal at a restaurant, both sides of the transaction understand who the client is. But when public servants serve the public, this customer/provider relationship is blurred.
When the customer/provider relationship is not apparent, and the profit motive is replaced by the goal of maximizing bureaucratic budgets or minimizing managerial accountability, inefficiencies often arise.
As a consequence, most economists prefer that goods and services be provided by private entities, unless this too has its failings. These failings could be in the failure to serve deserving but under-served markets, a tendency toward monopolies, or other failures in the market place. The recent past has painfully demonstrated that such market failures are not uncommon.
Economists also recognize that taxes can be used to discourage some activities that damage the economy, productivity, or the health of others. For instance, fees that discourage pollution or vice taxes that discourage smoking and drinking are legitimate taxes that redress the problems these activities create.
Unfortunately, politicians view taxes quite differently, as the examples of license plate fees, accelerated imposition of traffic tickets, and court surcharges demonstrate. The state views these taxation opportunities solely as opportunistic ways to raise revenue to support more spending. In doing so, it separates activities that spending support with any logical theory of who should pay for these services.
This separation of what we do and who should pay engenders cynicism and frustration. It also generates tremendous waste.
For instance, as the state strives to collect $129 million by forcing us all to go down to the DMV to swap perfectly good license plates, it completely disregards the significant cost of tax compliance. We incur greater expense by requiring overtime pay to the DMV employees who must serve this exodus of frustrated taxpayers. Meanwhile, each of us must take hours out of our day to deal with these lineups or mailings, and some of us will even have to hire or find others to physically swap the plates out — twice.
The staffing cost DMV will incur, and the value of our time sacrificed for nothing, makes the $129 million raised pale in comparison. Such a tax, while frustratingly easy to invoke, is incredibly expensive and inefficient. These compliance costs are just too high and too inefficient.
Equally misguided is the imposition of traffic tickets if the goal is simply to raise revenue. Of course, all of us would agree that the public should be protected from dangerous driving. Minor transgressions that pose no such danger would usually be forgiven at any other time but our current budget crises.
Such infractions might net the state a couple of hundred dollars a shot. The fines net perhaps about half that after court costs, trooper time, etc. However, the greater compliance cost is the hundreds of dollars of additional insurance fees that may occur because of such infractions.
It seems that the state is bent on raising revenue, a penny at a time, even if it costs its citizens dollars. Is there not a more politically courageous way to raise this revenue without generating additional and unproductive work for the DMV, state troopers and the courts? And would it not be possible just to send us all a tax bill without having us all pay more to out-of-state insurance companies, or waste our productive time waiting in lines?
These taxes, under the euphemisms of surcharges, fees, fines, etc., are still taxes by another name. Perhaps by calling these taxes something else, our political leaders believe they can claim taxes have not risen. In fact, they have, and by much more than the fees themselves. There is no redeeming aspect of this political opportunism — unless, of course, we finally realize this folly and just say no.
Colin Read is the former dean and now teaches economics and finance in the School of Business and Economics at SUNY Plattsburgh. His fourth book, "The Fear Factor," has recently been published by MacMillan Palgrave. He also runs an economic and business consulting company, and can be reached at economicinsights@gmail.com.
Columns
Discussion
ALSO NOTE: Derisive name-calling of an individual or group will result in the entire comment being deleted. This includes the terms "stupid" and "idiot" and similar references.
Welcome to our new online comments feature. Before you can join the discussion, you must first register with Disqus and verify your email address.
Once you do, your comments will post after they have been reviewed by a moderator.
We welcome your thoughts and your opinions, including unpopular ones. We ask only that you keep the conversation civil and clean.
Not all comments are deemed printable. Some are disqualified, at the newspaper’s discretion, for a number of reasons. Here are some typical practices to avoid in trying to get your comment printed:
There is a 150 word maximum for comments. All comments greater than 150 words in length will be deleted in their entirety.
Don’t state as a fact something that is unsubstantiated or that our editors wouldn't know to be true.
Don’t presume someone’s guilt in a case when it hasn't been established by a court.
Don’t assail or impugn an identifiable individual or group. If you have that kind of criticism, sign your name and submit it as a Letter to the Editor. (There is some leeway on this in connection with public officials, but it is not unconditional.)
Don’t use profanity. This includes the term “tea bagger.”
Don’t be incendiary or tasteless. Those qualities are subjective, of course, and our editors will be the arbiters.
Do not identify yourself in the main content area of the article content form. Only by enforcing this rule can the moderators prevent unscrupulous commenters from falsely identifying themselves as someone they are not.
Don't type in all caps. It is considered the Internet equivalent of shouting.
In sports articles, do not criticize officiating.
Remember, moderators are not allowed to edit any article comments. If an article comment fails any of the above criteria, the entire comment will be deleted.
We monitor comments Monday - Friday, 8 a.m. to 8 p.m. Saturday and Sunday, 2 p.m. to 8 p.m. Approval of comments outside these times may be delayed.
A tax by any other name is still a tax
Colin Read: Everybody's Business The Press Republican Sat Nov 21, 2009, 10:24 PM EST
- Columns
-
-
Know resting vitals before starting a workout program
A certified personal trainer can help you get the most out of your exercise program by administering a full health analysis, but some assessments can be done on your own, Ted Santaniello writes.
-
Rain, riverbank bring songs to mind
Gordie Little writes about how he often uses song lyrics to help describe how he feels.
-
Evictions: When and how
When a tenant or non-tenant refuses to leave an apartment at home, there are procedures to follow, writes Columnist Penny Clute.
-
Benefits of growing own food bountiful
If you are ready to get started right away, it is, in fact, a great time to begin a vegetable garden, Jordy Kivett writes.
-
Romney faces the Moral Majority
Speaking at Liberty University's commencement, Mitt Romney called on "people of different faiths" to meet in common purpose.
-
Battling weeds a busy job
The recent perfect combination of mild temperatures followed by a few days of soaking rains and then sun has created ideal growing conditions, Amy Ivy writes.
-
No, your baby is not adorable
It is chubby, hairless, wrinkled, toothless. It smells funny, and terrible stuff flows from nearly every orifice, Steve Ouellette writes.
-
A Greek Tragedy for us all
Greek voters are playing chicken with the world's economy, according to columnist Colin Read.
-
Social entrepreneurship a tool for nonprofits
In these days of decreased funding, nonprofit agencies have to be innovative, according to columnist Paul Grasso.
-
Tips for talking to teens about alcohol
Talk to your child about the dangers of alcohol long before they reach adolescence, columnist Dr. Lewis First writes.
- More Columns Headlines
-
- Peter Black: Canadian Dispatch
-
-
French voting in North America
There are reminders out there that the world, or at least a certain stratum of the world, once operated in French, Canadian columnist Peter Black writes.
Continued ...Anonymous The Press Republican Copyright 2012 Press-Republican. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.May 18, 2012 1 PhotoFri, May 18
- Conrad Black returns home May 4, 2012 1 Photo
- Tainted birthday for Canadian charter Apr 20, 2012 1 Photo
-
French voting in North America
- Lois Clermont, Editor
-
-
Editing Speakout is challenging
Speakout is overwhelmingly popular, emphasis on overwhelming, Editor Lois Clermont writes.
Continued ...LOIS CLERMONT, Editor The Press Republican Copyright 2012 Press-Republican. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.Apr 21, 2012 3:25 am 1 PhotoSat, April 21
- First Box isn't about winning a race Jan 2, 2012 2:25 am 1 Photo
- Never without a book Aug 1, 2011 3:25 am 1 Photo
-
Editing Speakout is challenging
- Cornell Cooperative Extension
-
-
Benefits of growing own food bountiful
If you are ready to get started right away, it is, in fact, a great time to begin a vegetable garden, Jordy Kivett writes.
Continued ...JORDY KIVETT, Good For You The Press Republican Copyright 2012 Press-Republican. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.May 22, 2012 1 PhotoTue, May 22
- Battling weeds a busy job May 21, 2012 1 Photo
- Farmers market benefit programs explained May 14, 2012 1 Photo
-
Benefits of growing own food bountiful
- Richard Gast: Cornell Ag Extension
-
-
Farmers markets open for season
No matter where you live in the North Country, a farmers market isn't far away.
Continued ...Richard Gast: Cornell Ag Connection The Press Republican Copyright 2012 Press-Republican. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.Jun 19, 2011 1 PhotoMon, June 20
- Cold frames extend season Apr 24, 2011 1 Photo
- Apple trees require special care Apr 10, 2011 1 Photo
Click here for more Richard Gast: Cornell Ag Extension stories
-
Farmers markets open for season
- Bob Grady
-
-
The importance of 'Fore' in golf
As the local golf season coasts to a close and golfers throughout the North Country begin to pack their clubs and frustrations away for another merciful respite, I'm compelled to report an incident that recently came to my attention involving my friend Ted and that diabolical sport, columnist Bob Grady writes.
Continued ...BOB GRADY The Press Republican Copyright 2012 Press-Republican. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.Nov 12, 2011 1 PhotoSat, November 12
- Having a tiger by the tail Sep 3, 2011 1 Photo
- Another nasty chore dispatched Jul 30, 2011 1 Photo
-
The importance of 'Fore' in golf
- Guest Columns
-
-
Evictions: When and how
When a tenant or non-tenant refuses to leave an apartment at home, there are procedures to follow, writes Columnist Penny Clute.
Continued ...By PENNY CLUTE, The Law and You The Press Republican Copyright 2012 Press-Republican. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.May 26, 2012 1 PhotoSat, May 26
- Welcome to Golf Month May 25, 2012
- Social entrepreneurship a tool for nonprofits May 20, 2012 1 Photo
-
Evictions: When and how
- Peter Hagar: Cornell Ag Connection
-
-
Farmers gearing up for busy spring
High-quality forage that's being produced now is key to bountiful milk production, according to columnist Peter Hagar.
Continued ...Peter Hagar: Cornell Ag Connection The Press Republican Copyright 2012 Press-Republican. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.May 13, 2012Sun, May 13
- Tractors on the move Apr 29, 2012 1 Photo
- Starting a small farm takes planning Apr 15, 2012 1 Photo
Click here for more Peter Hagar: Cornell Ag Connection stories
-
Farmers gearing up for busy spring
- Health Advice
-
-
Know resting vitals before starting a workout program
A certified personal trainer can help you get the most out of your exercise program by administering a full health analysis, but some assessments can be done on your own, Ted Santaniello writes.
Continued ...By TED SANTANIELLO, Fit Bits The Press Republican Copyright 2012 Press-Republican. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.May 29, 2012 1 PhotoTue, May 29
- Grasping the concept of hand strength May 15, 2012 1 Photo
- Diabetic alert dog a pleasant addition to family May 8, 2012 1 Photo
-
Know resting vitals before starting a workout program
- Ray Johnson: Climate Science
-
-
Climate change no longer a puzzle
Research has shown that our Earth is currently going through an energy imbalance, columnist Ray Johnson writes.
Continued ...RAY JOHNSON, Climate Science The Press Republican Copyright 2012 Press-Republican. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.May 6, 2012 4 PhotosSun, May 06
- Oceans seeing effects of rising temperatures Apr 1, 2012 4 Photos
- Dealing with the rising energy problem Mar 4, 2012 4 Photos
-
Climate change no longer a puzzle
- Gordie Little: Small Talk
-
-
Rain, riverbank bring songs to mind
Gordie Little writes about how he often uses song lyrics to help describe how he feels.
Continued ...GORDIE LITTLE, Small Talk The Press Republican Copyright 2012 Press-Republican. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.May 27, 2012 1 PhotoSun, May 27
- Always focus on the positive May 13, 2012 1 Photo
- Hung up on hanger collection Apr 29, 2012 1 Photo
-
Rain, riverbank bring songs to mind
- Terry Mattingly: On Religion
-
-
Romney faces the Moral Majority
Speaking at Liberty University's commencement, Mitt Romney called on "people of different faiths" to meet in common purpose.
Continued ...Terry Mattingly, On Religion The Press Republican Copyright 2012 Press-Republican. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.May 21, 2012 1 PhotoMon, May 21
- Professor Benedict lectures the professors May 14, 2012 1 Photo
- Stunning news for postmodern nuns May 7, 2012 1 Photo
-
Romney faces the Moral Majority
- Steve Ouellette: You Had To Ask
-
-
No, your baby is not adorable
It is chubby, hairless, wrinkled, toothless. It smells funny, and terrible stuff flows from nearly every orifice, Steve Ouellette writes.
Continued ...STEVE OUELLETTE, You Had to Ask The Press Republican Copyright 2012 Press-Republican. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.May 20, 2012 1 PhotoSun, May 20
- Expect obvious variety of summer flicks May 6, 2012 1 Photo
- Really no need to panic during test time Apr 22, 2012 1 Photo
-
No, your baby is not adorable
- Colin Read: Everybody's Business
-
-
A Greek Tragedy for us all
Greek voters are playing chicken with the world's economy, according to columnist Colin Read.
Continued ...COLIN READ, Everybody's Business The Press Republican Copyright 2012 Press-Republican. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.May 20, 2012 1 PhotoSun, May 20
- School-funding debate gets divisive May 13, 2012 1 Photo
- Spreading the word about recreation May 6, 2012 1 Photo
Click here for more Colin Read: Everybody's Business stories
-
A Greek Tragedy for us all
- Senior Thoughts
-
-
Memories live on with passing of special friends
Susan Tobias reflects on friendships with two women who left great legacies.
Continued ...SUSAN TOBIAS, Pinch of Time The Press Republican Copyright 2012 Press-Republican. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.May 16, 2012 1 PhotoThu, May 17
- Most taxes hard to decipher May 2, 2012 1 Photo
- Obits can be sad or informative Apr 18, 2012 1 Photo
-
Memories live on with passing of special friends
-


