PLATTSBURGH — Cumberland Head property owners rejected a proposed $12.2 million sewer project Wednesday night.
The vote was 376 opposed and 151 in favor.
Town Clerk Ricky Collins said there was a steady flow of voters throughout the day despite snowy, windy conditions.
Some Cumberland Head residents have asked for public sewer for a number of years, but the Plattsburgh Town Council found the costs too high.
That changed when the town was told it was eligible for a $5.3 million grant and $6.8 million loan from the U.S. Department of Agriculture earlier this year. The town passed a resolution to move forward, and opponents were able to get enough petition signatures to force a referendum vote.
There has been vocal opposition to the plan, mainly based on the cost to hook up to the new system and decommission functioning septic systems. Others questioned why every home is required to hook up when many say they have an adequate septic system.
Town Supervisor Bernie Bassett said the project will not go forward and the grant will not be utilized.
"The Town Council did what we are elected to do," he said.
"We found the funding to allow it to be brought to the voters and let them decide what they wanted to do. Obviously, a number of people were concerned."
Some voters took time to share their view of the proposal as they exited the polling place. Jim Varin said he was totally opposed.
"For me, it's totally a no-brainer," he said.
Varin said he could pay to pump out his system 20 times for what it will cost to connect to the proposed system. People who have a failing system should pay for its repair rather than burden those with functioning systems with this cost.
Phil Racine said it's a fact that Cumberland Head has shallow, poor soils that sit atop ledge rock. Many people say their system is working just because they can flush their toilet, he said, but the true test is if there is enough dry land for a leach field to absorb the wastewater produced.
While he does empathize with those who have invested so much in their septic systems, he would like them to look at the bigger picture.
"This (sewer project) is the right thing to do for our environment, our children and the people who will live on Cumberland Head in the future," he said. "It's important not to look at just the short-term gains, but look at the long-term gains for the environment."
Dr. Anthony Vaccaro said he feels taxes are already high enough. This is not the time to be putting additional taxes on the public, given the present economy.
"Although I feel it would be good for the health of the lake, this is a bad time to do it," he said.
Stuart Laidman said he has lived on Cumberland Head for 23 years and has never had a problem with his septic system. The cost to connect is just too much, not to mention the tax increase property owners would face during the 38-year term of the loan, he said.
Julie Steele-Goodwin said she thinks the plan was put together too rapidly. She agreed that burdening people with additional costs would create difficulties at this time.
"I think it's a waste of money," she said.
Terry Wiley said he voted in favor. He said people need to think beyond their personal situations and for future generations.
"I think it's an opportunity to take advantage of some funding that will not be available in the future. In the long term, it will improve property values and the water quality of the lake," he said.
John Pelkey said the main reason he was opposed is he's afraid it would lead to a huge increase in land development. He said he likes Cumberland Head as presently developed, and would even be in favor of slower, long-term development.
His wife, Jennie Pelkey, said she thinks the plan was rashly conceived. She's not convinced the proposed system would meet present needs, let alone the needs of future development.
If public sewer is to be installed, Mrs. Pelkey said, it should be a full-blown, standalone system.
Collins said there are presently 110 absentee ballots. That is not enough to change the outcome.
E-mail Dan Heath at: dheath@pressrepublican.com
Local News
Cumberland Head sewer plan rejected
Cumberland Head project would have been partly funded by feds
- Local News
-
-
NCCS wins CVAC cheerleading competition
NCCS wins first place for the eighth time in nine years
-
One injured in Plattsburgh house fire
A female suffered second- and third-degree burns in a fire at her South Catherine Street home early Sunday.
-
Plattsburgh's Sweet Adelines sing music of the heart
Sweet Adelines spread message of love on Valentine's Day with yearly singing valentines.
-
Ticonderoga faces severe school cuts
The district is starting its new budget process almost $2 million in the hole. Officials are seeking public input on the problem.
-
Tentative contract reached with officers
The deal with New York state would cover the 2,800 members of the New York State Correction Officers and Police Benevolent Association who typically work at specialized state centers such as the Sunmount Development Disabilities Services Office in Tupper Lake.
-
Attempted-murder trial set
The case against Robert J. McCann, who is charged with trying to kill his former girlfriend at a secluded Westville site, begins Tuesday in Franklin County Court.
-
A historic battle for interracial marriage
Forty-five years ago, the U.S. Supreme Court struck down all remaining state bans on interracial marriage in Loving v. Virginia.
-
Fireworks to close weekend carnival
The final day of the Saranac Lake Winter Carnival is filled with activities and events. INCLUDES VIDEO
-
Arts and economic development discussed
A success story about a theater in Glens Falls underscored the importance of the arts at a presentation put on by Partnership for Community Development in Plattsburgh.
-
Essex County launches flood-recovery grant outreach
The Empire State Development Flood Recovery Grant Program provides up to $20,000 in grant funds for businesses, farms and rental property recovering from flood damage.
-
In Montreal, amour is the word
Go on a romantic getaway north of the border for under $50.
-
Liquor and Wine Warehouse honored at national convention
The business was named a Brown-Forman Retailer of the Year and received the award at the American Beverage Licensees convention in Milwaukee.
-
Cost of the Market Basket remains steady in January
Costs mark the third consecutive month of good news for consumers.
-
Of Interest: Feb. 12, 2012
Peru Central School Board to hold budget discussion.
-
Business briefs: Feb. 12, 2012
New manager; Approved appraiser; Helicopter survey; Radio co-host; Disaster relief; Professional driver; New president; Business mixer; Fundraiser set; Web chat.
-
Farm briefs: Feb. 12, 2012
Registration open for pest-management training; Water-withdrawal reporting date approaching; Farm Bureau applauds pro-farm legislation;
- February 11, 2012
-
Attempted-murder trial set
The case against Robert J. McCann, who is charged with trying to kill his former girlfriend at a secluded Westville site, begins Tuesday in Franklin County Court.
-
United Way of the Adirondack Region exceeds goal
The 2012 campaign brought in $775,112.
-
NCCS wins CVAC cheerleading competition
- Recent Article Comments






