RAY BROOK — State Supreme Court has rejected a lawsuit brought by counties and towns against the Adirondack Park Agency over shoreline regulations.
The lawsuit, filed last spring by local governments, including Essex, Franklin and Clinton counties, claimed that a new APA regulation over waterfront residences built in the Adirondack Park before 1973 was made improperly and overstepped the agency’s legislative jurisdiction.
A clause built into the APA Act 30 years ago allowed existing shoreline property to be “grandfathered in” and exempt from stringent Adirondack construction setbacks of 150 feet from the water.
Many older camps, including historic former Great Camps, sit right beside the water’s edge.
Property owners could add on to their residences as long as expansion was planned to the back, away from the water.
The new regulation requires APA variance for any new construction on waterfront property and formal notice from shoreline homeowners planning even “minor expansion.”
NO GROUNDS
Seven Adirondack counties and numerous towns pooled resources and filed the lawsuit, which also claimed APA had not done proper economic-impact review to evaluate how the tightened rule would affect lucrative property-tax income from waterfront land.
Petitioners maintained APA was “trumping the intent of legislature” and had overstepped regulatory boundary.
But Supreme Court Justice Robert J. Muller rejected much of the counties’ argument.
“What has occurred here is that the administrative agency charged with interpreting and enforcing a statute has reconsidered a regulation it adopted years ago,” Muller wrote.
“The revised regulation, now adopted and in force, clearly takes a more restrictive view. The Court finds that none of the grounds alleged by petitioners invalidate the amendment.”
The Supreme Court also upheld APA jurisdiction over any subdivision of waterfront wetlands.
RULING AGAINST APA
Muller did rule, however, that “natural subdivision” created by existing roads on waterfront property cannot be removed from language in the regulation.
Fred Monroe, chairman of the Local Government Review Board, said this part of the decision provided an important win for local landowners.
“The more important thing is the court upheld the natural-subdivision rule. There are many people who own property on both sides of a road, and this creates separate lots you can sell without applying for subdivision approval from APA. The court decision means this rule is still alive.”
The judge also said APA overstepped its regulatory boundary by re-defining hunting and fishing cabins, in effect rewriting restrictions “not contemplated by the (State) Legislature.”
Muller ordered the new APA definition stricken from the shoreline amendment.
In the Town of Newcomb — one of the towns that sued — Supervisor George Canon said he was relieved to see the judge recognize APA overstepped boundaries.
“That’s a win as far as I’m concerned,” Canon said Monday night. “And it’s an important issue here. They tried to define hunting and fishing cabin use for only specific purposes, but my question is: What, are you going to have APA fishing and hunting cabin police? I’m glad the judge saw the fallacy in that.”
Canon the decision divided findings, some in APA’s favor, some in favor of local government.
“The ones we won I would say are the smaller end of the scale. I would rather have the decision allowing expansion on shoreline property, rather than the hunting and fishing cabins.”
APPEAL UNCERTAIN
“I guess we’ll (petitioners) have to get together to decide if an appeal is worth it or not,” Canon said.
Monroe also did not know whether the local governments would appeal.
“The attorneys are still reviewing it.”
Neither Canon nor Monroe have noted any measurable adverse economic impact yet from the new regulation, which has been in effect for about a year.
“I’ve heard from some contractors that it’s impacted their business,” Monroe said.
“We haven’t seen any impact yet on our assessed value. But I really believe that will happen. People are not going to buy an 800-square-foot cabin on the waterfront for a lot of money when they can’t do what they want with it.”
But APA Chairman Curt Stiles said the new regulation will actually improve the value of existing waterfront property by limiting new development.
INPUT LACKING
Asked what the park agency might have done better in creating the new regulation, Monroe said they could have vetted the change through local government.
“They could have done what it says in APA Act, which is consult with Local Government Review Board; consultation to me means some kind of meaningful dialogue. It did happen, but very, very late in the process — in September, before they adopted this last November.
“APA is charged with the responsibility of fostering a continued planning process, which recognizes matters of local concern. And that’s what we should be doing.”
E-mail Kim Smith Dedam at:
kdedam@pressrepublican.com
Local News
Towns lose lawsuit over APA shoreline rules
- Breaking News
-
-
Montreal woman dies in Westport crash
Angela Pierre, 69, was ejected from the vehicle when its driver lost control on Interstate 87 in Westport.
-
Burlington hospital makes interim chief permanent
Fletcher Allen Health Care announced today that Dr. John Brumsted will move from interim to permanent president and CEO.
-
Montreal woman dies in Westport crash
- New Today
-
-
Recovery Center to hold open house
Smashing stereotypes and eliminating the stigma of mental-health issues has led to formation of a new place in Franklin County for clients to get wrap-around services to help them rejoin the community.
-
Recovery Center to hold open house
- Local News
-
-
Ticonderoga faces severe school cuts
The district is starting its new budget process almost $2 million in the hole. Officials are seeking public input on the problem.
-
One injured in Plattsburgh house fire
A female suffered second- and third-degree burns in a fire at her South Catherine Street home early Sunday.
-
Plattsburgh's Sweet Adelines sing music of the heart
Sweet Adelines spread message of love on Valentine's Day with yearly singing valentines.
-
Love between the lines
Dr. Nell Irvin Painter of New Russia and Plattsburgh State's Dr. J.W. Wiley share historical and current viewpoints on interracial loving, American-style.
-
NCCS wins CVAC cheerleading competition
NCCS wins first place for the eighth time in nine years
-
Cheerleading photos (2/12/12)
-
Tentative contract reached with officers
The deal with New York state would cover the 2,800 members of the New York State Correction Officers and Police Benevolent Association who typically work at specialized state centers such as the Sunmount Development Disabilities Services Office in Tupper Lake.
-
Lookback: Feb. 13-19
News stories from around the region from 25, 50, 75 and 100 years ago this week.
-
Of Interest: Feb. 13, 2012
Peru Central School Board to hold budget discussion; Dannemora to discuss highway post; Beekmantown School Board invites budget input; Willsboro School Board to discuss policies; Chazy School Board to discuss budget; SLCS Board to appoint clerk pro-tem; Keeseville Zoning Board cancels meeting; Elizabethtown-Lewis School Board to work on budget.
-
Gourds' shapes create interesting canvas
Georgette Bacon's gourd art is on display through March 10 at Foothills ARTSociety in Malone.
- February 12, 2012
-
NCCS wins CVAC cheerleading competition
NCCS wins first place for the eighth time in nine years
-
One injured in Plattsburgh house fire
A female suffered second- and third-degree burns in a fire at her South Catherine Street home early Sunday.
-
Plattsburgh's Sweet Adelines sing music of the heart
Sweet Adelines spread message of love on Valentine's Day with yearly singing valentines.
-
Ticonderoga faces severe school cuts
The district is starting its new budget process almost $2 million in the hole. Officials are seeking public input on the problem.
-
Tentative contract reached with officers
The deal with New York state would cover the 2,800 members of the New York State Correction Officers and Police Benevolent Association who typically work at specialized state centers such as the Sunmount Development Disabilities Services Office in Tupper Lake.
-
Attempted-murder trial set
The case against Robert J. McCann, who is charged with trying to kill his former girlfriend at a secluded Westville site, begins Tuesday in Franklin County Court.
-
A historic battle for interracial marriage
Forty-five years ago, the U.S. Supreme Court struck down all remaining state bans on interracial marriage in Loving v. Virginia.
-
Fireworks to close weekend carnival
The final day of the Saranac Lake Winter Carnival is filled with activities and events. INCLUDES VIDEO
-
- Recent Article Comments
Raw Video: Israeli Embassy Car Attacked
Coroner: Don't Know Houston's Cause of Death Yet
Valentine Greetings Sent Worldwide From Loveland
Greek Austerity Measures Spark Riots
Raw Video: Obama Budget Goes to Capitol Hill
Arab League Wants U.N. Help in Syria
Nordic Festival Puts North Korea in Spotlight
'Rumor Has It' Adele's Rolling in the Grammys
Grohl, Grammy Nominees Cut Up on the Red Carpet
Greece Passes New Austerity Deal Amid Rioting
Raw Video: Greek Rioting Ahead of Austerity Vote
Raw Video: Child Rescued After Kosovo Avalanche
Pop Music Superstar Whitney Houston Dies at 48
Whitney Houston's Church Mourns Her Passing
Reaction to Houston's Death at Clive Davis Party
79 Turtles Seized at Shanghai Airport
Fuel Removal Under Way on Capsized Italian Ship
Police: Houston Found Dead in Her Hotel Room
