PLATTSBURGH —
By REBECCA WEBSTER
Staff Writer
PLATTSBURGH — Heritage Automotive employee Melinda S. Labrie answered a call on Dec. 27, 2005, from the phone number of the House of Pine and Oak in Schuyler Falls.
She was taking calls for appointments for the South Burlington business that day, she testified on Thursday, during the retrial of Edward A. Dashnaw.
He is accused of murdering David and Lorraine Donivan of Schuyler Falls in December 2005; they owned of the House of Pine and Oak.
Labrie said the person who called Heritage identified himself as “Joe” and said he was trying to get a vehicle towed to the garage from the Grand Isle, Vt., ferry parking lot.
It wouldn’t start, she said he told her.
“He said he was just a messenger,” she said, and then gave her the name “Donivan.”
Labrie said she asked for a callback number.
Shown a photo of a House of Pine and Oak truck outside a wooden building, she verified that the phone number on the truck was the one she was given that day.
MORE QUESTIONS
Earlier on Thursday, Dashnaw — who is handling his own defense — continued cross-examination begun Wednesday of forensic document examiner Dennis Ryan.
Dashnaw began with questions about a document he had tried to utilize Wednesday in the courtroom, entitled “Strengthening Forensic Science in the United States: A Path Forward.” The defendant said the article, written in 2009, states that some forensic document examiners make erroneous matches when evaluating writing.
Ryan was familiar with the author but unfamiliar with the article.
“I’m unsure if what I saw yesterday ... is the same article you are referencing,” he told Dashnaw.
Dashnaw told the court he had only a portion of the article and proceeded to move on to question Ryan about receipts from the stores FYE and Aeropostale that had been presented Wednesday.
“Can you specifically point to an item you used to draw the conclusion that (Mrs. Donivan) did not sign the Aeropostale receipt?” Dashnaw asked.
Ryan reiterated that he could rule her out because of her skill level and the pictorial differences between her writing and that of whomever signed the receipt.
SEEMED FRUSTRATED
Dashnaw asked, “Which (known writings) did you use to draw the conclusion?”
“(I) use the entire set (of known writing) that’s given to me, and that’s compared to the questioned writing,” Ryan explained.
Dashnaw began to question Ryan on how much money he receives from the state for testifying in trials.
Ryan said he’s paid $1,800 a day.
After a handful of objections from District Attorney Andrew Wylie, Dashnaw seemed frustrated.
“I’m not very good at this questioning thing,” he said.
Clinton County Judge Patrick McGill told Dashnaw that he had told him when he decided to continue pro se that he would have to question witnesses.
WINDING DOWN
After Wylie told McGill that he had no more witnesses for that session, Dashnaw objected to the fact that he had been “forced” to continue on Wednesday when he had asked for some time to prepare his questions. Dashnaw said testimony could easily continue.
Wylie placed on the record the three witnesses they would see on Monday in order for the defense to have additional information.
McGill explained that it is difficult to schedule witnesses.
“This is not an exact science, and these things take the time they take,” he said. “We are dealing with human beings.”
Dashnaw asked McGill if he could stay for an hour in the courtroom after all were excused to look over the exhibits. McGill granted his request.
But before he dismissed the jury, McGill said, “I anticipate that we will conclude (the prosecution side) sometime next week.”
PAST CONVICTION
In March 2006, Dashnaw was indicted on 11 charges in connection with the murders and was convicted in April 2007 of each charge except second-degree murder. The latter charge had been included for the jury’s consideration as a lesser inclusive charge of first-degree murder, which means he could not have been convicted of both.
After his 2007 conviction, Dashnaw was sentenced to concurrent terms of life without parole for the first-degree murders.
But this June, the Appellate Division of State Supreme Court granted Dashnaw a new trial after finding that certain statements he made to police should not have been used in his original trial because a lawyer was not present at the time.
Dashnaw, now, 42, had been serving time at a downstate prison. He is now held without bail at Clinton County Jail.
The trial will resume at 9:30 a.m. Monday in Clinton County Court.
Email Rebecca Webster at:
rwebster@pressrepublican.com
Local News
Dashnaw trial may be winding down
- Local News
-
-
Beekmantown Central faces major cuts
Superintendent Scott Amo proposes eliminating more than 40 positions and the district's entire athletic program.
-
Civil-rights claim against superintendent upheld
In a preliminary decision, the Federal Equal Employment Opportunity Commission says Dr. Randy Richards did discriminate against a principal. And a petition with 600 signatures asks him to resign.
-
Accused says he's 'sorry for what I did'
Attempted-murder suspect Robert J. McCann tells a Franklin County jury steroids he used are to blame for his alleged aggression against his ex-girlfriend.
-
Route 22 condition called terrible
Essex County officials want the state road from Willsboro to Chesterfield resurfaced soon.
-
Attorney found no merit in appeal
Appellate court grants counsel's request to be removed from the case, saying issues brought up by convicted rapist Jason W. Annette of Tupper Lake were frivolous.
-
No contested races in northern Franklin County
Voters in the villages of Brushton, Burke and Chateaugay will go to the polls March 20.
-
Plattsburgh State promotes positive workplace
The college's Civility in the Workplace Steering Committee hopes to foster teamwork among college employees through a series of surveys, workshops and distribution of educational materials.
-
Saranac man to pay for fraud charges
Donald R. Velie Jr. was charged in August with worker's compensation fraud, based on allegations that he was receiving benefits while holding a side job.
-
Flying nun shows savvy travel sense
North Country Mission of Hope's Sister Debbie Blow was not about to let 300 pairs of reading glasses for the needy disappear at Managua Airport in Nicaragua.
-
Of Interest: Feb. 23, 2012
Congressional candidate plans meeting; Altona Town Offices closed this Friday; Beekmantown Fire Auxiliary seeks members; Booster Club case due back in court; City Council to consider street drives; Malone College Club offers scholarships.
-
Clinton County Property Transfers:Feb. 6 to 16, 2012
A list of land transactions in Clinton County Feb. 6 to 16, 2012.
- February 22, 2012
-
Accused says he's 'sorry for what I did'
Attempted-murder suspect Robert J. McCann tells a Franklin County jury steroids he used are to blame for his alleged aggression against his ex-girlfriend.
-
Civil-rights claim against superintendent upheld
In a preliminary decision, the Federal Equal Employment Opportunity Commission says Lake Placid Central School Superintendent Dr. Randy Richards did discriminate against a principal. And a petition with 600 signatures asks him to resign.
-
Structure fire fizzles
Flames were doused quickly at 169 Grew Road in Mooers this afternoon, canceling the call for mutual-aid help.
-
Beekmantown may cut 40 jobs, all sports
At Tuesday's School Board meeting, Superintendent Scott Amo also proposed reductions to arts and music, cutting back to minimum requirements on state-mandated services and making other reductions to bridge a $3.2 million budget gap for 2012-13.
-
Forest rangers rescue hiker from Mount Marcy
Separated from his hiking party Monday, Stephen Mastaitis spent a frigid night on the mountain with wind chill near 20 below.
-
Attempted-murder trial resumes
Robert J. McCann of Brushton returns to Franklin County Court as testimony continues in the 11-count case against him for allegedly harming, stalking and raping his former girlfriend.
-
Northeast sees massive bee losses
Champlain Valley Beekeepers Association President Dick Crawford said beekeepers he has talked with have seen deaths of between 90 percent and 100 percent.
-
Beekmantown Central faces major cuts
- Recent Article Comments
Romney, Santorum Assail Each Other in GOP Debate
New Radar Confirms Tornadoes Faster
Police: Wash. School Shooting Accidental
Fitness Program Improves Lives of Mentally Ill
NJ Officials Blast NYPD Over Spying Report
2nd Degree Murder Verdict in Lacrosse Slaying
GOP Rivals Pass Contraception Debate, Hit Obama
Romney, Santorum Swap Charges in 20th Debate
Raw Video: Guilty Verdict in UVa Lacrosse Death
$5 Gas Coming to Pumps Near You?
Raw Video: French Police Release Strauss-Kahn
Ga. Spa Shooting Leaves 5 Dead, Victims Related
2 More Western Journalists Die in Syria
7 Killed As Afghan Quran Protests Turn Violent
Santorum Goes After Obama on Energy
Judge Says Lindsay Lohan in the "Home Stretch"
Father Accused of Using Leash on 11 Year Old
Obama Helps Break Ground on Black History Museum
Raw Video: Dozens Dead in Argentina Train Crash
Wounded Vets Regain Some Camaraderie in Kitchen
