ALBANY, N.Y. (AP) — The state board that oversees New York museums may consider allowing them to sell artwork, artifacts and other works to pay back debt, a change of policy some museum backers say would threaten quality collections.
The state Board of Regents started working on an "emergency amendment" to the rules governing how museums can manage collections because it appeared that Fort Ticonderoga, a historic site and museum in northern New York, was on the verge of bankruptcy, said James Dawson, chairman of the board's Cultural Education Committee.
Fort Ticonderoga last summer said it wanted to sell some of its works — including a painting by Thomas Cole thought to be worth millions — to help erase about $2.5 million in debt. But state rules currently require museums to use the money from such sales only to buy other works or enhance their collections.
The emergency amendment would allow museums to sell off works to pay down debt if they can show that they have no other way to raise the money and would otherwise go bankrupt. The museums also would only be allowed to sell the works to another museum or historical society in New York.
The Board was to have taken up the amendment at a meeting Monday but Dawson — who represents northern New York on the Board of Regents — said he withdrew the proposal Thursday, partly because Fort Ticonderoga was able to raise enough money to stay out of bankruptcy court.
"Since the emergency has been removed, we don't need to do it," he said.
He couldn't say how much Fort Ticonderoga had raised, and museum officials declined to comment to The Associated Press.
Dawson said the Board of Regents will revisit the issue early next year as part of a broader review of museum rules and regulations.
"In the fiscal climate the country and the state are in right now, we can see additional cultural institutions coming into fiscal crisis," he said. "We need to have a procedure for dealing with that."
The idea of museums cashing in on their collections in challenging budget times is generally frowned upon in the art world. Dawson said he heard a lot of opposition to the proposed rule change, including from some other Board of Regents members.
The state proposal also became known just weeks after the National Academy in Manhattan, which is not subject to the Board of Regents' rules, sold two Hudson River School paintings to shore up its finances.
That move drew a strong rebuke from the Association of Art Museum Directors, which asked its members to stop working with the academy.
"Collections should not be used to support operating budgets," said Michael Conforti, the association's president and director of the Clark Institute in Williamstown, Mass.
Museums nationwide have faced cash crunches in the faltering economy as the value of their endowments slides and governments and philanthropists have fewer dollars to contribute.
But few appear to have been squeezed to the point where they're considering selling off their collections, said Dewey Blanton, a spokesman for the American Association of Museums. Doing so would be considered a breach of ethics, he said.
Anne Ackerson, director of the Museum Association of New York, said her group was among those opposing the idea of allowing museums to sell their collections to pay debts. While it might be a short-term fix for some museums' financial problems, it might dissuade others from seeking other solutions when money gets tight, she said.
"We don't think this is the right thing to do in the long term," she said.
The Board of Regents rules governing the sale of museum holdings were established in the early 1990s when the New York Historical Society faced financial problems.
Assemblyman Richard Brodsky, a Queens Democrat who chaired an investigative committee at the time, said he was happy to hear the Board of Regents had withdrawn the emergency amendment proposal but remained concerned that they might still try to tweak other parts of the rules that define what qualifies as part of a museum's collection.
Brodsky said he urged the Regents to hold off on making any changes until after a more thorough review involving museums, the Legislature and others with an interest.
Local News
NY museums may be able to sell works to pay debt
- Local News
-
-
Woman not guilty in arson case
A Franklin County jury cleared Nancy G. Nixon of Saranac Lake on charges that she deliberately set fire to an apartment house last May.
-
Woman charged with robbing 96-year-old
Man gets order of protection against Saranac Lake woman.
-
Schumer supports maple-production legislation
Plan would provide funds to allow maple producers to tap into thousands more trees in Upstate New York.
-
Malone flood buyout sought
Franklin County asking Feds to buy out 10 damaged homes.
-
Mental-health agencies eye new gun law
Mental-health agencies, among them Behavioral Health Services North, now must comply with new gun-law dictates officials feel increase stigma and may discourage people from getting help.
-
Drug charges follow hazmat incident
After six Border and Protection officers were sent to the hospital on Saturday, a New Hampshire man was charged with criminal possession of a controlled substance and unlawful possession of marijuana.
-
Sexual predator gets 20 years
A Paul Smiths man, Elwood Adams Jr. preyed upon two young girls for years, Franklin County prosecutors report.
-
Queen of Hearts winner picked
American Legion fundraiser ends with $100,000 jackpot after nearly a year of weekly drawings, mostly to packed houses in the Rouses Point establishment.
-
Three schools hold budget re-votes today
Newcomb, Minerva and Tupper Lake districts amended their budgets after earlier defeats.
-
Durnin wins open seat on NACS board
Will fill unexpired term that runs through June 2015
-
Volunteer monitors needed for blue-green algae
The Lake Champlain Committee is seeking help identifying potentially dangerous blooms this summer.
-
Students: June 18, 2013
Academic achievements by students from the North Country.
-
Of Interest: June 18, 2013
Take a brief look at news of note around the North Country.
-
Bariatric surgery offers several options for weight loss
The Adirondack Medical Center Bariatric Program offers several procedures that doctors will share with patients in making a decision on how to move forward with weight loss.
- June 17, 2013
-
Forum airs state-test frustrations
Area teachers, parents and school officials gathered recently at AuSable Valley Central to discuss the state's new controversial assessments and related mandates.
-
Test forum panelists call for action
Panelists at AuSable Valley Central School's recent forum on state testing urged the public to voice their concerns to the State Education Department.
-
Essex County tourism shows effective marketing
More visitors are coming to the region in response to Internet information and social media than ever before.
-
Woman not guilty in arson case
