MALONE -- A Burke Town Council member has 10 days to give legal reasons why turning over wind-farm-project documents to a grand jury could violate his constitutional rights.
Acting Franklin County and St. Lawrence County Supreme Court Judge David Demerest told David Vincent on Tuesday he has until April 18 to explain in more detail, with supporting case law, why he should be excluded from turning certain information over to a grand-jury investigation.
But Demerest also instructed Vincent to have the paperwork in question ready for him to read in private if the final ruling does not go in Vincent's favor.
WIND DOCUMENTS
Vincent, through attorney Brian Barrett of Lake Placid, is challenging a grand-jury subpoena from District Attorney Derek Champagne asking for "any and all" documents that could personally connect him to the Noble Chateaugay Windpark, Noble Energy, Jericho Rise Windpark and Burke Wind Power.
The grand jury wants to see all correspondence, contracts, receipts, leases, purchase agreements, options or communications from 2006, 2007 and 2008 that the councilman may have had with any representatives of the wind-farm projects being proposed in the towns of Chateaugay, Burke and Bellmont.
RIGHTS
But Barrett argues that his client's right to privacy, his right to avoid self-incrimination and his right to be protected from unlawful search and seizure would be violated if he were to turn over the requested material.
He characterized the DA's subpoena as "a fishing expedition" and said Champagne is trying to get around obtaining a proper search warrant by issuing a subpoena instead.
Barrett said the grand-jury process is "cloaked in secrecy" and that the DA "has a wide latitude to tell the grand jury what he wants."
That could mean some of the paperwork the DA seeks might disclose personal information about his client that has nothing to do with the investigation, Barrett said.
RESISTS LIMITS
Chief Assistant District Attorney John Delehanty, who represents Champagne in the action, argued a grand jury has specific duties and functions and therefore its power is to be far-reaching and thorough in determining whether to seek a criminal indictment against someone or not.
He said the request for a subpoena "is presumptively appropriate" and should never be scrutinized or limited.
Delehanty said it is up to grand jury to decide if requested material has relevance it its investigation, not Vincent, and that it is his duty to respond to the order.
He said the subpoena challenge is frivolous, suggesting that Vincent be held in contempt of the order.
But Demerest said Vincent is not refusing to comply with request; he is exercising his right to refute the subpoena.
Therefore, there is no basis for contempt charges, he said.
Vincent has until April 18 to give the judge his legal reasons for not wanting to turn over documents, and Delehanty has until April 25 to respond.
The judge expects to make a decision before May 1, when the next group of grand jurors is impaneled.
draymo@pressrepublican.com
Local News
More time given to the Burke councilman challenging a grand-jury probe
Grand jury wants data related to windfarm role
- Local News
-
-
Attempted-murder trial set
The case against Robert J. McCann, who is charged with trying to kill his former girlfriend at a secluded Westville site, begins Tuesday in Franklin County Court.
-
United Way of the Adirondack Region exceeds goal
The 2012 campaign brought in $775,112.
-
Clinton County to consolidate voting districts
The move is aimed at saving towns and the City of Plattsburgh money for hosting elections.
-
Waterway projects approved for Essex County
The State Emergency Management Office has so far identified 26 sites that need flood-mitigation or remediation; funding has come through for nine so far.
-
Area schools battle against time
Teachers and administrators around the North Country struggle over how to meet state mandates while providing quality education.
-
Champlain snowmobile crash results in serious injuries
Douglas M. Tetreault and Robert Worrell were transferred to Fletcher Allen Health Care in Burlington from CVPH Medical Center in Plattsburgh following the early morning accident along the Great Chazy River.
-
Parade highlights carnival festivities
Many other events are on course for the Saranac Lake Winter Carnival this weekend.
-
Saranac Lake man loses appeal
Christopher R. Baker considered his sentence harsh and excessive.
-
Moriah Chamber being revived
New leaders are cranking up the Moriah Champ Day and Labor Day celebrations, along with other efforts.
-
Fire at SUNY Canton shuts down campus
No one was hurt when flames erupted in Cook Hall on Friday, but students were sent home, and classes are canceled through next week.
-
Of Interest: Feb. 11, 2012
Plattsburgh State College Council to meet; Annual tax-exemption deadline approaching; LPCS Board to work on spending plan; Chateaugay Board to discuss food program.
-
Clinton County Property Transfers:Jan. 30 to Feb. 3, 2012
A list of land transactions in Clinton County Jan. 30 to Feb. 3, 2012.
-
Parents Night Out offers fun for kids and parents, too
Plattsburgh Church of the Nazarene offers special event as community service the first Friday of every month.
- February 10, 2012
-
Fire at SUNY Canton shuts down campus
No one was hurt when flames erupted in Cook Hall on Friday, but students were sent home, and classes are canceled through next week.
-
Moriah Chamber being revived
New leaders are cranking up the Moriah Champ Day and Labor Day celebrations, along with other efforts.
-
United Way of the Adirondack Region exceeds goal
The 2012 campaign brought in $775,112.
-
Clinton County to consolidate voting districts
The move is aimed at savings towns and the City of Plattsburgh money for hosting elections.
-
Waterway projects approved for Essex County
The State Emergency Management Office has so far identified 26 sites that need flood-mitigation or remediation; funding has come through for nine so far.
-
Attempted-murder trial set
- Recent Article Comments
Police: Houston Found Dead in Her Hotel Room
Paul Suffers Narrow Loss to Romney in Maine
Recording Superstar Whitney Houston Dead at 48
Maine GOP Chairman Says Romney Wins Caucuses
Palin Brings Anti-Washington Message to CPAC
Obama Scraps Birth Control Mandate
US Airmen's Killer Sentenced to Life in Germany
Navy Names Ship for Gabrielle Giffords
Raw Video: Deadly Blasts in Syria
Romney Slams President Obama at CPAC
Gingrich: Pres. Obama 'waging War on Religion'
5 Killed in Wrong-way Crash on I-10 in La.
Uzbek Man Pleads Guilty in Plot to Kill Obama
Denver's Largest-Ever Drug Bust Nets Dozens
Marines: No Punishment for Nazi-like Flag
Vets Look to Translate Military Skills Into Jobs
Raw Video: School Bus Burst Into Flames
LA School Reopens Amid Sex Abuse Scandal
$25B Settlement Reached Over Foreclosure Abuses
Pentagon: Allow Women Closer to Front Lines
